Episode 44 – Jessica Dorsey on the Negotiations over Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems in the CCW

Jessica Dorsey

In this episode I speak with Jessica Dorsey of Utrecht University about the negotiations on lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS) within the framework of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) in Geneva. Jessica is a Washburn Law alumna who went on to graduate work at Utrecht University and the University of Amsterdam, and worked at the T.M.C. Asser Instituut, among other European institutions, before joining the faculty at Utrecht. A scholar of drone warfare and, more recently, of AI-enabled targeting and autonomous weapons, she has advised political, legal and policy institutions on these issues for many years, and took part in the CCW negotiations as a civil-society expert.

The debate over whether autonomous weapons can comply with IHL in all circumstances, and whether IHL as it stands can adequately govern them, has run within the CCW for more than a decade. It gained new momentum in 2023, when the CCW’s Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) was mandated to formulate the elements of an instrument on LAWS, leaving open whether it would be binding, in time for the Seventh Review Conference in 2026. The Chair’s “rolling text” went through several iterations, attracted growing support from States as a basis for negotiating a binding treaty, and became the substance of the GGE’s report, adopted in the early hours of 5 September 2026.

Our conversation covers how those negotiations developed and what the definition of LAWS captures and excludes, including AI targeting and decision-support systems such as those used in Gaza and Iran. It also covers why many States believe new law is needed, and how a handful of States resisted and diluted the text’s limitations. We discuss the dynamics of the final session, which ran late into the night, behind closed doors and without interpretation. Finally, we look at the prospects for the Seventh Review Conference, 16–20 November 2026, which some see as the last best chance to establish global governance of so-called killer robots.

Materials:

– Report of the 2024–2025–2026 Sessions of the Group of Governmental Experts on Emerging Technologies in the Area of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems, U.N. Doc. CCW/GGE.1/2026/3 (Sept. 2026).

– GGE on LAWS, Rolling Text (5 June 2026).

– Jessica Dorsey, Rain Liivoja, Netta Goussac, Sally Longworth & Anna Andersson, “Symposium on the CCW GGE LAWS: The End of the Beginning – An Introduction,” Opinio Juris, Oct. 5, 2026.

– Jessica Dorsey, “You Can’t Always Get What You Want – The (D)evolution of Responsibility and Accountability,” Opinio Juris, Oct. 9, 2026.

– International Committee of the Red Cross, Working Paper submitted to the CCW GGE on LAWS (Aug. 2026).

Reading Recommendations:

– Elke Schwarz, “The Hacker Way” (book chapter, CRC Press).

– Elke Schwarz, Death Machines: The Ethics of Violent Technologies (Manchester University Press, 2018).

– Zena Assaad & Lt. Col. Adam Hepworth, “AI DSS and the Erosion of Technical Integrity: Rethinking Human Decision-Making in Modern Warfare,” Australian Army Research Centre.

– Zena Assaad & Jessica Dorsey, “Designing Lawful Military AI: Technical and Legal Reflections on Decision-Support and Autonomous Weapon Systems,” Perry World House, University of Pennsylvania, Nov. 24, 2025.

Episode 37 – Martin and Hafetz on “Eye in the Sky”

This episode is a joint production and cross-posting with the Law on Film Podcast, produced and hosted by Jonathan Hafetz, a professor of law at Seton Hall Law School, and expert in national security law, international criminal law and human rights, as well as constitutional law. We discuss the film “Eye in the Sky,” a 2015 film likely known to most JIB/JAB listeners,  about a joint British and American drone strike against al-Shabaab terrorists in Kenya, and which intelligently and engagingly explores the legal, ethical, philosophical, political, and strategic issues raised by the operation. We not only examine the film’s treatment of the legal issues implicated, including whether IHL should apply at all, and how the principles of distinction, necessity, proportionality, and precautions in attack are illustrated in the film, but we also explore the relationship between these principles and some of the ethical and strategic aspects of the decision-making in the film. We round out the conversation with a discussion of some other engaging films that similarly explore law in the context of armed conflict. I very much enjoyed the conversation!

Materials:

– Craig Martin, A Means-Methods Paradox and the Legality of Drone Strikes in Armed Conflict, 19:2 Int’l J. Human Rights 142 (2015).

– House of Lords and House of Commons Joint Committee on Human Rights, The Government’s Policy on the Use of Drones for Targeted Killing, Second Report, 2015-16 (2016).

– Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Instruction, No-Strike and Collateral Damage Estimation Methodology, Feb. 13, 2009.

Movie Recommendations:

– Taxi to the Darkside (2007)

– Breaker Morant (1980)

– Paths of Glory (1957)

– A War (2015)